Resumen
The question of how the different legal orders work jointly is one of the issues most studied by legal scholars. Various theories have arisen trying to explain it, oscillating between monism and dualism. Among these proposals is the theory of transconstitutionalism, put forward by Brazilian professor Marcelo Neves; through conceptual assumptions unrelated to law, he claimed to have achieved an all-encompassing answer to this question. Based on a correlational methodology, this article aims to critically approach this theory, demonstrat-ing that it has been overvalued in terms of its functionality and usefulness, particularly in the relations between international law and domestic law in the Latin American context.
Título traducido de la contribución | Transconstitutionalism: Theory without Practice? Critical Analysis of One of the Current Theories on the Relations between Legal Orders |
---|---|
Idioma original | Español |
Número de artículo | e3124 |
Páginas (desde-hasta) | 1-35 |
Número de páginas | 35 |
Publicación | Dikaion |
Volumen | 31 |
N.º | 2 |
DOI | |
Estado | Publicada - 11 ago. 2022 |
Nota bibliográfica
Funding Information:Artículo de investigación que expone, parcialmente, los resultados preliminares del proyecto posdoctoral de uno de los autores, el cual es financiado por la Universidad de los Andes, Chile, a través del Fondo de Ayuda a la Investigación.Agradecimientos Los autores agradecen a la profesora Paola Andrea Acosta Alvarado por sus comentarios a una versión preliminar de este trabajo.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2022, Universidad de La Sabana. All rights reserved.
Palabras clave
- domestic law
- inter-order relations
- international law
- legal orders
- Transconsitutionalism