Investigating the Microstructural and Textural Properties of Cookies Using Plant-Based Bigel as an Alternative to Commercial Solid Fat

In response to the growing demand for improving the nutritional profile of widely consumed products, such as cookies, there has been an increasing interest in fat replacers that preserve sensory attributes and have a more positive health effect. Among the novel fat replacement strategies, the incorporation of bigels into food formulations has been studied; however, the impact of Arabic gum hydrogel-based bigels on microstructural properties and their correlation with the texture and quality of bakery products remains underexplored. In this study, cookies were formulated using a plant-based bigel (canola oil-carnauba wax oleogel mixed with Arabic gum hydrogel) as a fat substitute, and their microstructural, textural, and quality parameters were compared with those of commercial butter-based cookies. Compared to butter (firmness of 29,102 g, spreadability of 59,624 g∙s, and adhesiveness of 2282 g), bigel exhibited a softer (firmness of 576 g), more spreadable (spreadability of 457 g∙s), and less adhesive texture (adhesiveness of 136 g), while its rheological properties showed similar behavior but at a lower magnitude. Bigel exhibited high thermal stability and good elastic and thixotropic behaviors, indicating reversible structural breakdown and recovery. Cookies prepared with bigels instead of butter exhibited a similar proximate composition, with a slight increase in lipid content (11.7%). The physical dimensions and density were similar across the formulations. However, the microstructural analysis revealed differences when bigels were incorporated into cookies, reducing porosity (55%) and increasing the mean pore size (1781 µm); in contrast, mean wall thickness remained unaffected. Despite these structural modifications, the potential of bigels as viable and nutritionally enhanced substitutes for conventional fats in bakery products was demonstrated.